Weightlifting EWF European Championships 2021

[Olympian1010 8,073]

It’s ridiculous that bodyweight isn’t the tiebreaker in my opinion. Hopefully that’s one of the reforms that the IWF will make in the future. 

[thiago_simoes 1,425]

  On 4/9/2021 at 2:15 AM, Olympian1010 said:

I could be wrong, but I thought there used to be (perhaps still is) a rule that the first lifter to lift the weight held the tie break.

Expand  

Thank you. Somehow, I failed to realize how weird the rules are for such a simple sport. It's like they were bored with the way things were and decided to change everything based on arbitrary decisions.

 

 

  On 4/9/2021 at 2:31 AM, MHSN said:

btw the fact that this Bulgarian kid can't qualify for the Olympics just shows how terrible is this system. it closed the door for any young talent because you had to collect points from 2018! how old he was when the qualification period started?

Expand  

I wonder why some federations act like this. Stupid rules that prevent the best athletes from competing should not exist. Period. It's pretty much like artistic gymnastics where we'll have a very limited girl from Singapore competing at the Olympics, while extra gymnasts from Ukraine, Brazil and Australia will have to stay home, even though their level is miles ahead of what the Singaporean girl can reach. At this point, in artistic gymnastics I don't feel like the best will compete at the Olympics, but instead we'll see lots of smaller nations with very poor displays of gymnastics simply because the IOC wants "diversity". I'm all in for diversity, but if a gymnast can't reach a bare minimum level compared to the top guns, so leave this person home.
 

[Federer91 2,902]

  On 4/9/2021 at 2:31 AM, MHSN said:

 

btw the fact that this Bulgarian kid can't qualify for the Olympics just shows how terrible is this system. it closed the door for any young talent because you had to collect points from 2018! how old he was when the qualification period started?

Expand  

He was only 14 in 2018, so very, very early to compete amongst the men. But still, this doesn't exclude how absolutely awful the qualification system has been in this sport.

[Mecki83 155]

  On 4/9/2021 at 2:34 AM, Olympian1010 said:

It’s ridiculous that bodyweight isn’t the tiebreaker in my opinion. Hopefully that’s one of the reforms that the IWF will make in the future. 

Expand  

I think that the new system is better. All athletes are really close to the limit weight, so we are only speaking about a few gramms which doesn`t really matter for the performance.

On the other hand an athlete has a huge disadvantage if he has to decide first on the next weight and the second athlete only has to wait and decide afterwards. So it is only fair to give the first to decide this advantage.

[dcro 10,210]

Agreed. Body weights are too random for a tie break.

[MHSN 3,660]

I think @Mecki83 is right, I also never heard any complain about this rule from the WL community. it seems everybody likes it and nobody is going to change it.

 

it makes sense actually, before 2005 it was minimum 2.5kg between your 3 attempts. which was a relatively big jump, now it's just 1kg. if your rival lifted 200kg, just go and beat him by 1kg more. if you lift the same number "after him" you probably don't deserve to rank higher than him.

[heywoodu 15,353]

Did Strenius really just miss the Olympics because her coaches decided to have 135kg as second CJ attempt instead of 131kg (which she might have made and which would have been enough)?  

[MHSN 3,660]

  On 4/10/2021 at 10:03 AM, heywoodu said:

Did Strenius really just miss the Olympics because her coaches decided to have 135kg as second CJ attempt instead of 131kg (which she might have made and which would have been enough)?  

Expand  

this is probably nonsense, I can say 100% nonsense, the Olympic Ranking is way too much complicated , so many variables, nobody can calculate points like that especially before the other continental championships, and 4kg more or less won't make a huge different. she will probably qualify even without her results from this competition.

[heywoodu 15,353]

  On 4/10/2021 at 10:28 AM, MHSN said:

this is probably nonsense, I can say 100% nonsense, the Olympic Ranking is way too much complicated , so many variables, nobody can calculate points like that especially before the other continental championships, and 4kg more or less won't make a huge different. she will probably qualify even without her results from this competition.

Expand  

Right, somehow I had a feeling already that the British Eurosport commentator (Michaela Breeze) might not be entirely right...  

 

She's getting a little annoying anyway, I didn't see a single Russian lifter yet which was not accompanied by her saying something about Russia's doping past. If that's about one of the many medalists who actually served a doping ban, sure, but literally everyone?  

[rybak 3,239]

Damn it, with "help" from judges Michalski finished without medal despite lifted 226kg in CJ  At least Kasabijew have a small silver medal. But still those championships are pathetic for us, without medals in total, just third time in history of European Champs....

 

Anyway I hope that Michalski's 396kg in total will be enough for Olympics, what do you think @MHSN?