website statistics
Jump to content
  • Register/Login on Totallympics!

    Sign up to Totallympics to get full access to our website.

     

    Registration is free and allows you to participate in our community. You will then be able to reply to threads and access all pages.

     

    If you encounter any issues in the registration process, please send us a message in the Contact Us page.

     

    We are excited to see you on Totallympics, the home of Olympic Sports!

     

Marathon Swimming at the Aquatics WA World Championships 2024


Recommended Posts

29 minutes ago, intoronto said:

This is essentially the point I was making about reallocations in canoe slalom. The hierarchy of the allocations can change the outcome. However, I'm not sure Israel has a winning argument here.

 

Quote

Israel Swimming finds this to be inconsistent with the qualification procedures, which calls for the unused host country spot to go to the next highest NOC not already qualified

don't see that in the language regarding the host country quota. The text (from the version I viewed [25.01.2023]) states, "next highest placed athlete(s)." It doesn't seem to restrict NOCs with one quota from being allocated a second.

 

In terms of the reallocation of Oceania's quota, I do think they are correct about the language. However, I think they are wrong about the hierarchy. Oceania's quota technically can't be allocated at the same time as the other quotas, since it doesn't have some of the contingencies bestowed to those. I believe it would trigger the formal reallocation process outlined in section F, which (in my analysis of the document and results) would result in the quota being awarded to :CAN.

 

Of course, this post is based on my interpretation of the qualification document, which could be flawed.

“Sport has the power to change the world. It has the power to inspire. Sport can create hope where once there was only despair” - Nelson Mandela

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/24182-marathon-swimming-at-the-aquatics-wa-world-championships-2024/page/12/#findComment-608499
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

So I guess someone in the women's event rejected a quota that went to :PER María Bramont-Arias, who was 25th in the qualifier and the next in line ¿¿????

Edited by Jur
Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/24182-marathon-swimming-at-the-aquatics-wa-world-championships-2024/page/12/#findComment-619215
Share on other sites

https://www.worldaquatics.com/news/3952855/paris-2024-marathon-swimming-re-allocation-of-quota-position

 

Does anyone know why now 23 women marathon swimmers are qualified? All 22 accepted their quota and yet there was a re-allocation to :PER?

Edited by Arnoud Beldman
Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/24182-marathon-swimming-at-the-aquatics-wa-world-championships-2024/page/12/#findComment-620386
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Arnoud Beldman said:

https://www.worldaquatics.com/news/3952855/paris-2024-marathon-swimming-re-allocation-of-quota-position

 

Does anyone know why now 23 women marathon swimmers are qualified? All 22 accepted their quota and yet there was a re-allocation to :PER?

Yes, that's a mistery :mumble:

 

I have asked World Aquatics on X :d

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/24182-marathon-swimming-at-the-aquatics-wa-world-championships-2024/page/12/#findComment-620408
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, Arnoud Beldman said:

https://www.worldaquatics.com/news/3952855/paris-2024-marathon-swimming-re-allocation-of-quota-position

 

Does anyone know why now 23 women marathon swimmers are qualified? All 22 accepted their quota and yet there was a re-allocation to :PER?

 

9 hours ago, Sindo said:

Yes, that's a mistery :mumble:

 

I have asked World Aquatics on X :d

A contradiction regarding how the host country quota gets reallocated is my interpretation.

 

Paragraph D1.2 of the qualification document mentions that an unused host country quota ends up to the next highest placed athlete from 2024 World Championships. This would mean Brazil, as their athlete finished 14th.

 

However, paragraph F2 states that an unused host country place is reallocated to the next highest placed NOC from 2024 World Championships, provided that the NOC is not yet qualified. If this is applied after handing out continental quotas, Peru is first on the line. 

 

Peru's federation first reported that they got a quota on 13 March, much earlier than world aquatics. 

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/24182-marathon-swimming-at-the-aquatics-wa-world-championships-2024/page/12/#findComment-620492
Share on other sites

31 minutes ago, maestro said:

 

A contradiction regarding how the host country quota gets reallocated is my interpretation.

 

Paragraph D1.2 of the qualification document mentions that an unused host country quota ends up to the next highest placed athlete from 2024 World Championships. This would mean Brazil, as their athlete finished 14th.

 

However, paragraph F2 states that an unused host country place is reallocated to the next highest placed NOC from 2024 World Championships, provided that the NOC is not yet qualified. If this is applied after handing out continental quotas, Peru is first on the line. 

 

Peru's federation first reported that they got a quota on 13 March, much earlier than world aquatics. 

Probably that's it. They are giving an extra quota to Peru, simply because they don't know how to be clear in their documents. :lol:

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/24182-marathon-swimming-at-the-aquatics-wa-world-championships-2024/page/12/#findComment-620502
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Posts around Totallympics

    • More highlights   21.89 WL for  Gabby Thomas in the women's 200m at the Kip Keino Classic,  Cambrea Sturgis not far behind in a huge PB of 21.96    Rumesh Tharanga Pathirage continues his strong stretch of form with a 89.28m effort in men's javelin throw, just off his NR of 89.37m  Sinesipho Dambile with a PB of 19.77 in the men's 200m   10.03 PB for 18 year old  Gary Card in the men's 100m at the Penn Relays
    • Does the CAS have the authority to address from someone who believes the judges made a mistake in a given discipline? Pizzolato's last attempt at Paris 2024, which earned him the bronze medal, was controversial, but what does the CAS have to do with it? Even if the judges made a mistake then, the result won't change and this isn't the only case where someone feels wronged with this in world of sports. Unless, of course, they have some evidence of corruption or something like that
    • If Pizzolato will to return, would it be to the 86 kg category, or the 94 kg category, like Nasar? In 2024, they were both in the 89 kg category, which will no longer be at the Olympics, but in 2021 in Tokyo, Pizzolato won a medal in the 81 kg category.   Of course, it's unclear what's going on with the rape accusations- personally, unfortunately, I don't think he was ever a sweet angel- he was accused of other immoral things also 10 years ago, but gang rape? I find that hard to believe... Besides, Moldova has appealed about his bronze medal from Paris 2024 to the CAS- the verdict was supposed to be in February. Do you know anything about this? Did they have any grounds for this lawsuit at all?
    • Ukraine won 6 gold medals out of 10 in the women's competotion  + 1 silver and 1 bronze. Where do they get these girls from? It's always been a strong country, but they have never dominated like this. I wonder if their training methods would work in another country and if their coaches have any offerts to job from other countries? However, there is a significant decline in women's judo in Ukraine, so maybe they have directed all their resources and money towards wrestling?   In fact, Ukraine dominates Europe as much as Japan does the world- they have the best school in women's wrestling. In 2024, Ukraine only won 1 silver medal at the Paris Olympics? So even domination in Europe doesn't guarantee even 1 gold medal at the Olympics. Although, of course, if Italy for example, can't even win 1 bronze medal at the European Championships, then there's no point in even going to the World Championships...
    • Sablikova started on the road cycling and just almost qualified for Rio 2016. Maybe Lollobrigida would like to join the Italian track team? She has the good character and 2 medals at the Olympics, one in winter and one in summer, would be a legendary achievement, not only in Italy.   https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martina_Sáblíková
    • One Wiebes is worth more than the all Italian team with Balsamo/Fidanza, etc., that much clear. Even if the Netherlands loses its dominance in the men's sprint, Wiebes will win 2-3 gold medals in other events. Just relax, man.
    • I'm most worried about our women's team in the pursuit – we have a reserve squad, but not advancing to the top 8 is a shame. We recently competed with out 1 team and had not good in 1 round. It doesn't look good. And the Netherlands are already taking Wiebes to the track team and will soon dominate the Madison/Omnium as well. Balsamo and Paternoster haven't made any progress for years and the our women's team at the Olympics has little chance to win a medal. Italy might even win World Championship/European Championship gold in the years after the Olympics, etc., but when the real fight comes, the UK or the USA will always beat us
    • Track cycling is one of the few sports where there is no host nation quota, so  will need to work hard to achieve our quotas.  It's not our best sport, but was happy to see Top 10 results in the Elimination Race for Grant Koontz and Emma Jimenez Palos (who is just 18!).
    • Yes, I saw the same thing you did @clemsonbeav (on both accounts) but I agree it looks pretty stock.  
×
×
  • Create New...