website statistics
Jump to content

Alpine Skiing FIS World Cup 2019 - 2020

Totallympics

By Totallympics,
in Alpine Skiing

 Share

Recommended Posts

Gianlu33 Proficient

Gianlu33   4,559

Posted
Posted
35 minutes ago, phelps said:

let's not say ***...the highest seeded athlete could pick the course as always...

 

apparently, a few girls however didn't realize that the blue course was faster...

I think that i missed something, i was sure that they change the format :mumble::facepalm:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Replies 933
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

hckošice
hckošice

First race of the season start list https://www.fis-ski.com/DB/general/results.html?sectorcode=AL&raceid=100025

heywoodu
heywoodu

Thanks Italian hckosice

Posted Images

phelps Experienced

phelps   7,675

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, Gianlu33 said:

I think that i missed something, i was sure that they change the format :mumble::facepalm:

 

today eurosport's broadcaster (Gian mario bonzi) said more than once that the top seed had the chance to pick the course he wanted...

 

therefore I assume it was really that way...

Link to comment
Share on other sites
NearPup Rising Star

NearPup   3,045

Posted
Posted
3 hours ago, heywoodu said:

This PGS in Sestrieres was ridiculous :lol: 

 

How come the highest-ranked athletes aren't allowed to choose the course? Or are they and was every single one of them so dumb they picked the obviously slower red course?

They should really only allow 16 qualifiers and have a two run format. Basically the old city event format, but with two qualifying runs.

 

I really hate the one run format in parallel races.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Monzanator Proficient

Monzanator   4,502

Posted
Posted
15 minutes ago, NearPup said:

They should really only allow 16 qualifiers and have a two run format. Basically the old city event format, but with two qualifying runs.

 

I really hate the one run format in parallel races.

 

Can't have both. Either two-run format or 32 racers instead of 16.

 

However you'd think a two-run format for 32 racers would be doable in a single-gender event like this. But they'd have to get rid of the qualifying stage.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
NearPup Rising Star

NearPup   3,045

Posted
Posted
41 minutes ago, Monzanator said:

 

Can't have both. Either two-run format or 32 racers instead of 16.

 

However you'd think a two-run format for 32 racers would be doable in a single-gender event like this. But they'd have to get rid of the qualifying stage.

I think 16 is the only number that allows both a fair competition and a good TV product.

 

I basically want the same format alpine snowboarding used before they went to this one run nonsense.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Monzanator Proficient

Monzanator   4,502

Posted
Posted
3 minutes ago, NearPup said:

I think 16 is the only number that allows both a fair competition and a good TV product.

 

I basically want the same format alpine snowboarding used before they went to this one run nonsense.

 

One part of the course will always be more favored IMO so it's down to what FIS wants. These one-run events could be more unpredictable, a two-run thing would probably result in a Shiffrin vs Vlhova final 9/10 times. Question is whether FIS is okay with someone like Direz being a World Cup winner?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
heywoodu Mentor

heywoodu   15,140

Posted
Posted
6 hours ago, NearPup said:

They should really only allow 16 qualifiers and have a two run format. Basically the old city event format, but with two qualifying runs.

 

I really hate the one run format in parallel races.

No matter how many athletes are in, two runs is definitely the only fair way to go.

 

And if you're so desperate not to have two runs all the time, like FIS seems to be, do the exact opposite of what they've got now: one run in the first round and then switch to two runs.

.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
phelps Experienced

phelps   7,675

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, Dunadan said:

There was a draw - Shiffrin was critical of this procedure during the interview just after the race with Rai Sport.

 

but when? and for what?

 

because I don't think there was a new draw in between every round...:mumble:

 

if the draw was just to fill the 1st round pairings, it really didn't have any influence on the race...

 

the initial question was only if the best seeded athlete could pick their favourite course in the 1-run heats (and according to eurosport commentator that happened) or not?

 

obviously, a fair 16 qualified athletes + a 2-run system in each round would be a lot better, but still this wasn't the case (and most likely it won't be also in the near future)...

 

 

however, with yesterday's format we have:

 

- 1st round: 16*2 = 32 heats

- 1/8 finals: 8 heats

- QTFs: 4 heats

- Semis: 4 heats (because they also keep those senseless -and dangerous for somehow demotivated athletes- 5th/8th place playoffs)

- Finals: 4 heats (see above, semis description)

 

Total: 52 heats and more than 90 mins TV time

 

with 16 qualifiers and a permanent 2-run system we have:

 

- 1/8 finals: 8*2 = 16 heats

- QTFs: 4*2 = 8 heats

- Semis: 2*2 = 4 heats (and get rid of the 5th/8th place playoffs, you can easily rank the skiers eliminated in the QTFs according to their qualification time, as they should do also for the earlier rounds, just to give more sense also to the single placings in the qualification runs)

- Finals: 2*2 = 4 heats

 

Total = 32 heats and most likely no more than 50/55 mins TV time (for the happiness of all the international broadcasters and to cope better with the young people's very limited attention span)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Latest Posts around Totallympics

    • copravolley
      Speed Skating ISU World Cup 2024 - 2025

      By copravolley · Posted

      Tragic performance of the Italian women's team - last place and probably something bad happened at the start. There are so few starts in the team that it will be a problem to even qualify for the World Championships - 8 best teams. After Lollobrigida's return and Fontana's addition, I was counting on much more, but it seems that there are too few joint trainings. With individual quality, we have no right to lose to the Czechs without Sablikova, or anonymous Korea. And unfortunately this start will count for a lot, because there are only 2 more and our chances of playing at the World Championships are minimal. In my opinion with Fontana going from Short Track to Long Track, there won't be much use in the team. Here, great teamwork is needed, not improvisation. As of today, there is very little chance that we will qualify the women's team for the games.
    • Monzanator
      Curling WCF European Championship 2024

      By Monzanator · Posted

      men advanced to Division A for the first time since 2018 (when they went 1-8). Don't expect much progress next year
    • copravolley
      Alpine Skiing FIS World Cup 2024 - 2025

      By copravolley · Posted

      Ok, but there we are talking about a person who has parents from different countries. Colturi has nothing to do with Albania.
    • copravolley
      Alpine Skiing FIS World Cup 2024 - 2025

      By copravolley · Posted

      There are few people here from Austria, Switzerland, Norway and Finland.
    • copravolley
      Milano Cortina 2026 vs Torino 2006

      By copravolley · Posted

      The worst editions in XXI century for us were Vancouver: 5 medals (only 1 gold for Razzoli's on the penultimate day) and Sochi: 8 medals (but no gold). Turin was already a prelude to this bad period, although the number of gold medals was ok. Overall we won fewer medals at home than in 2002 and this was probably the only case in the 21st century when the host country won fewer medals at home than 4 years earlier, either in summer or winter. In general the years 2008-2016 were very bad in our sport, both in summer and winter. Only 2018 in Korea was a slight rebuild + 2 fantastic summer editions in Tokyo and Paris. in Beijing 2022 we won a lot of medals - 17 but only 2 gold (If it weren't for Gogga's injury, I think it would have been 4 gold).
    • Olympian1010
      Alpine Skiing FIS World Cup 2024 - 2025

      By Olympian1010 · Posted

      Totallympics had  users at one point, but I haven't seen any hanging around in a while.
    • Josh
      Milano Cortina 2026 vs Torino 2006

      By Josh · Posted

      In terms of total medals, yes. In terms of golds, I’d be fine with anywhere from 6-8.   @intoronto you don’t think we’ll do better or at least the same? Bit surprising.
    • copravolley
      Open Water Swimming WA World Cup 2024

      By copravolley · Posted

      Tadeucci was very good and took bronze
    • Gianlu33
      Milano Cortina 2026 vs Torino 2006

      By Gianlu33 · Posted

      On the Olympics I don't like to count golds to analyse the performance, I think the best data are the top8 and medals. In both fields I expect a big improvement (obviously not on the 'pure' number, but on the percentage of medal or top8 events)
    • heywoodu
      Cross-Country Skiing FIS World Cup 2024 - 2025

      By heywoodu · Posted

      December is probably going to be focused on either Italy/Austria or Norway, but the plans are still being made as we speak. Renting a car, driving from the Netherlands down to Italy, finding accomodations and help with preparing the skis and all that...trying to make it as an independent 'solo' athlete is...hard     I can't go and help out, because we got the keys to our house (finally) and there's lots of work to be done there, so it's all happening at the same time and the mind is getting crazy (for both of us)  
×
×
  • Create New...