[POLL] Posting results and medal tables

[heywoodu 15,135]

There's quite a lot of discussion about the posting of results and medal tables and how that's supposed to happen. To get a bit of an idea what everyone's opinions are, I think a poll could help out a little.

Of course there are probably more options possible, I only tried to get the most "common" options together. It's possible to vote for more than one option, so at least select 1 Results and 1 Medals option please

Edited March 13, 2016 by heywoodu

[vlad 359]

I voted for the old format, but if can't be possible than at least we should post the podiums in all events.

[heywoodu 15,135]

By the way, apologies for the long sentences, I could have chosen a bit better way  

[hckošice 14,823]

I think, one of the options to be take on consideration is.

Post the full results of the Olympic Sports World and Continental Championships, with a medal standing at the end of the day.

Post medalists or top 6/top 10 of each olympic sport event (not a World or continental Championship) like a world cup, Grand Prix, world tour stage etc... and adding a link for the remaining standing. (or adding them on the spoiler)

Post only medalists in non-olympic sports, no need medal table.

 

but ofc, we have to try first, how to post results, because this software isn´t the best option for posting results, like was discuss

[heywoodu 15,135]

Just now, hckosice said:

I think, one of the options to be take on consideration is.

Post the full results of the Olympic Sports World and Continental Championships, with a medal standing at the end of the day.

Post medalists or top 6/top 10 of each olympic sport event (not a World or continental Championship) like a world cup, Grand Prix, world tour stage etc... and adding a link for the remaining standing. (or adding them on the spoiler)

Post only medalists in non-olympic sports, no need medal table.

 

but ofc, we have to try first, how to post results, because this software isn´t the best option for posting results, like was discuss

 

Imagine there is a competition with 100 participants at a World Championships. Why would you not post the top-3/6 in the normal way and put the rest in a spoiler? 

 

If you don't put them in a spoiler --> You need to scroll past all 100 names to go to the next post

If you put them in a spoiler --> You only have to scroll past one sentence that says "This is a spoiler, click to see it" (or something like that) but still all 100 names are there..

 

I just honestly don't know any argument why not to use this spoiler option for bigger results than say 3 names.

[uk12points 434]

53 minutes ago, hckosice said:

I think, one of the options to be take on consideration is.

Post the full results of the Olympic Sports World and Continental Championships, with a medal standing at the end of the day.

Post medalists or top 6/top 10 of each olympic sport event (not a World or continental Championship) like a world cup, Grand Prix, world tour stage etc... and adding a link for the remaining standing. (or adding them on the spoiler)

Post only medalists in non-olympic sports, no need medal table.

 

but ofc, we have to try first, how to post results, because this software isn´t the best option for posting results, like was discuss

I fully agree with this!

 

This can ensure we have detailed coverage of the most important events, whilst keeping the excellent range of other events results that makes Totallympics so unique.

[uk12points 434]

49 minutes ago, heywoodu said:

 

Imagine there is a competition with 100 participants at a World Championships. Why would you not post the top-3/6 in the normal way and put the rest in a spoiler? 

 

If you don't put them in a spoiler --> You need to scroll past all 100 names to go to the next post

If you put them in a spoiler --> You only have to scroll past one sentence that says "This is a spoiler, click to see it" (or something like that) but still all 100 names are there..

 

I just honestly don't know any argument why not to use this spoiler option for bigger results than say 3 names.

I don't like the idea of spoilers because for major events all results should be seen and available without having to click on a spoiler, which can be easily missed and detracts from the point of posting the full results.

But for smaller events, top 10/medallists only would be sufficient and there would be no need to post the remaining results in a spoiler.

[Werloc 3,164]

Well, I'm stating my opinion. I voted for three of the choises.

Number 1: Results posted as before - I picked this choise for multiple reasons. Firstly, Totallympics was usually the only place where I could easily find results for some sports that our media does not cover (yes, even those that have Lithuanians taking part in it). Also, I know that the topics used to get flooded with heat results, but there are many sports where heat results are majorly important.

Number 2: Medalists + Spoilers that reveal the full results. Even if the option 1 is not available, I still really want to be able to see the results. The spoiler function would help those members who don't want the threads to be covered with flags and I'm ok with that, just as long as I have the chance to find the results on the forum.

Number 3: Medal tables should be posted at the end of the competition - I don't see a huge reason to post medal tables at the end of day, I think the medal table is important information only when the competition is actually over.

[heywoodu 15,135]

5 minutes ago, uk12points said:

I don't like the idea of spoilers because for major events all results should be seen and available without having to click on a spoiler, which can be easily missed and detracts from the point of posting the full results.

But for smaller events, top 10/medallists only would be sufficient and there would be no need to post the remaining results in a spoiler.

But in that case major events should have 2 threads: one in which only results are posted and nothing else, and one for discussion. Because threads of major events in which huge lists of results are posted become almost unreadable for some people (my browser often nearly exploded with the overload of results and moving flags and everything)

[heywoodu 15,135]

6 minutes ago, Werloc said:

Well, I'm stating my opinion. I voted for three of the choises.

Number 1: Results posted as before - I picked this choise for multiple reasons. Firstly, Totallympics was usually the only place where I could easily find results for some sports that our media does not cover (yes, even those that have Lithuanians taking part in it). Also, I know that the topics used to get flooded with heat results, but there are many sports where heat results are majorly important.

Number 2: Medalists + Spoilers that reveal the full results. Even if the option 1 is not available, I still really want to be able to see the results. The spoiler function would help those members who don't want the threads to be covered with flags and I'm ok with that, just as long as I have the chance to find the results on the forum.

Number 3: Medal tables should be posted at the end of the competition - I don't see a huge reason to post medal tables at the end of day, I think the medal table is important information only when the competition is actually over.

I agree especially with your number 2. Don't get me wrong, I find it very important to have a lot of results from especially smaller sports and competitions.

Federations like FIS and IBU already have their own, much better results databases and sports like athletics and cycling have a thousand sites where it's easier to find what you want. However, many federations have a very messed up way of putting results online and so having them on the forum is extremely useful.

 

My one and only complaint is the huge lists of results and flags and huge letters and colours and everything that makes some threads look like a children's website project and completely the opposite of a place where you can discuss as well. With spoilers it's much "cleaner" and you still have all results (which I find important, I love the results of smaller sports).

Edited March 13, 2016 by heywoodu