website statistics
Jump to content
  • Register/Login on Totallympics!

    Sign up to Totallympics to get full access to our website.

     

    Registration is free and allows you to participate in our community. You will then be able to reply to threads and access all pages.

     

    If you encounter any issues in the registration process, please send us a message in the Contact Us page.

     

    We are excited to see you on Totallympics, the home of Olympic Sports!

     

Karate 2018 Discussion Thread


thepharoah

Recommended Posts

6 ore fa, MHSN ha scritto:

 

I think I exactly asked for such change in Kata scoring system. having a number as the final score is much better than just a 5-0 or 4-1 which doesn't show the real difference between two competitors.

 

the new Kata format is also interesting. what if we have less than 16 competitors ? we still should have those 1st/2nd rounds or we can go directly to the pre-final round . what about the Olympics with only 10 competitors ? 2 groups of 5 and then after one round of Kata, group winner to the final ?

 

and finally 3 minutes competition for women. even though I still prefer 4 minutes for both gender but still this is better than only 2 minutes !!! still no extra time but positive changes in general.

 

good questions...but, at least for now, still without an answer...

I think they will let us know those details in the next months, after looking carefully at the outcome of the new system in the first K1PL and Serie A events of the 2019...:mumble:

 

p.s. if I have to guess, in Tokyo they could go for a preliminary round with 2 groups of 5 and the top 4 advancing to the main round...then 2 groups of 4 with the groups' winners making the Gold medal match and the 2nd and 3rd of each group making the Bronze medal bouts (crossover between the 2 groups of course), so to have at least 2 kata before the finals (only 1 would be really a shame)...

but it's only my personal guess...:dunno:

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/791-karate-2018-discussion-thread/page/8/#findComment-186450
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, phelps said:

 

good questions...but, at least for now, still without an answer...

I think they will let us know those details in the next months, after looking carefully at the outcome of the new system in the first K1PL and Serie A events of the 2019...:mumble:

 

p.s. if I have to guess, in Tokyo they could go for a preliminary round with 2 groups of 5 and the top 4 advancing to the main round...then 2 groups of 4 with the groups' winners making the Gold medal match and the 2nd and 3rd of each group making the Bronze medal bouts (crossover between the 2 groups of course), so to have at least 2 kata before the finals (only 1 would be really a shame)...

but it's only my personal guess...:dunno:

 

having a round to eliminate just one athlete doesn't make sense unless they keep the scores for the 2nd round. I mean using the total score to detemine the finalists. they can also having all 5 athletes having 2 rounds.  because I agree only 1 would be really a shame

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/791-karate-2018-discussion-thread/page/8/#findComment-186473
Share on other sites

12 ore fa, MHSN ha scritto:

 

having a round to eliminate just one athlete doesn't make sense unless they keep the scores for the 2nd round. I mean using the total score to detemine the finalists. they can also having all 5 athletes having 2 rounds.  because I agree only 1 would be really a shame

 

I agree...wasting 1 round to eliminate just 2 athletes out of 10 doesn't make a lot of sense, but after watching at least 2 consecutive Games where in women's waterpolo they didn't eliminate a single team in the group stage (all 8 teams advancing to quarterfinals) or Eights crews in Rowing with heats and repechage (2 rounds!) used to eliminate just 1 single boat, nothing's gonna surprise me anymore in terms of weird and senseless competition formats (and it's gonna happen also in Tokyo, with the Baseball tournament -the craziest and most unfair format I haver seen at the Olympics)...

 

p.s. keeping the score of both rounds would be a good idea...and I also would ask the athletes to perform 2 different Kata in round #1 and round #2 (not daring to ask for a 3rd different Kata in the finals yet, though)...

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/791-karate-2018-discussion-thread/page/8/#findComment-186502
Share on other sites

That's the Kata olympic format in the post above.

Here's the link to download the new rulebook https://wkf.net/pdf/rules/WKF Competition Rules 2019_EN.pdf-eng.pdf in case anyone is interested

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/791-karate-2018-discussion-thread/page/8/#findComment-186512
Share on other sites

3 minuti fa, Dunadan ha scritto:

 

Y2SVr45.png

nlgB8W4.png

 

:yikes:

talking of weird and redundant formats...:pope::rofl::facepalm:

 

p.s. by the way, thanks a lot...I should have checked it out personally...but, as I always write, I'm too lazy...and in these days my laziness it's even more extreme...:facepalm:

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/791-karate-2018-discussion-thread/page/8/#findComment-186513
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Latest Posts around Totallympics

    • I hope this isn’t one of those venues that has one course that almost always wins, otherwise it’ll make for some very boring racing. 
    • Rooting for  Goggia and Brignone to bring home some medals today, of course! 
    • TEAM CUBA      Pitchers: Frank Alvarez (Vegueros de Pinar del Rio, CNS, ) Emmanuel Chapman (Pittsburgh Pirates, MLB, )* Josimar Cousin (Rioleros de Aguascalientes, LMB, ) Naykel Cruz (Baltimore Orioles, MLB, )* Daviel Hurtado (New York Mets, MLB, )* Denny Larrondo (Unattached, ) Yoan Lopez (Algodoneros Union Laguna, LMB, ) Raidel Martinez (Yomiuri Giants, NPB, ) Randy Martinez (Vegueros de Pinar del Rio, CNS, ) Livan Moinelo (Fukuoka SoftBank Hawks, NPB, ) Darien Nunez (Algodoneros Union Laguna, LMB, ) Julio Robaina (Tigres de Quintana Roo, LMB, ) Osiel Rodriguez (Unattached, ) Yariel Rodriguez (Toronto Blue Jays, MLB, )* Luis Romero (El Aguila de Veracruz, LMB, ) Pedro Santos (Gigantes de Carolina, LBPRC, )   Catchers: Omar Hernandez (Kansas City Royals, MLB, ) Andrys Perez (Cocodrilos de Matanzas, CNS, )   Infielders: Erisbel Arruebarrena Yiddi Cappe (Miami Marlins, MLB, )* Yoan Moncada (Los Angeles Angels, MLB, ) Malcom Nunez (Unattached, ) Alexei Ramirez (Vegueros de Pinar del Rio, CNS, ) Alexander Vargas (Cincinnati Reds, MLB, )* Yoel Yanqui (Avispas de Santiago de Cuba, CNS, )   Outfielders: Alfredo Despaigne (Alazanas de Granma, CNS, ) Yoelkis Guibert (Avispas de Santiago de Cuba, CNS, ) Ariel Martinez (Hokkaido Nippon-Ham Fighters, NPB, ) Leonel Moas Jr. (Toros de Camaguey, CNS, ) Roel Santos (Olmecas de Tabasco, LMB, )   *minor league player
    • TEAM PANAMA      Pitchers: Dario Agrazal (Leones de Yucatan, LMB, ) Logan Allen (Cleveland Guardians, MLB, ) Alberto Baldonado (Yomiuri Giants, NPB, ) Jaime Barria (Algodoneros de Union Laguna, LMB, ) Miguel Cienfuegos (San Diego Padres, MLB, )* Paolo Espino (Criollos de Caguas, LBPRC, ) Jorge Garcia (Bravos de Margarita, LVBP, ) Miguel Gomez (Bravos de Leon, LMB, ) James Gonzalez (Athletics, MLB, )* Javy Guerra (Atlanta Braves, MLB, ) Kenny Hernandez (Tigres de Quintana Roo, LMB, ) Ariel Jurado (Samsung Lions, KBO, ) Humberto Mejia (Chunichi Dragons, NPB, ) Abdiel Mendoza (Seattle Mariners, MLB, )* Andy Otero (El Aguila de Veracruz, LMB, ) Erian Rodriguez (Chicago Cubs, MLB, )*   Catchers: Miguel Amaya (Chicago Cubs, MLB, ) Leonardo Bernal (St. Louis Cardinals, MLB, ) Christian Bethancourt (Chicago Cubs, MLB, )* Ivan Herrera (St. Louis Cardinals, MLB, )   Infielders: Jonathan Arauz (Saraperos de Saltillo, LMB, ) Jose Caballero (New York Yankees, MLB, ) Johan Camargo (Tecolotes de los Dos Laredos, LMB, ) Leo Jimenez (Toronto Blue Jays, MLB, ) Edmundo Sosa (Philadelphia Phillies, MLB, ) Ruben Tejada (Caliente de Durango, LMB, )   Outfielders: Enrique Bradfield Jr. (Baltimore Orioles, MLB, ) Allen Cordoba (Diablos Rojos del Mexico, LMB, ) Jose Ramos (New York Mets, MLB, )* Jhonny Santos (Unattached, )   *minor league player
    • That sucks for viewers... Screaming Chad is the worst
    • TEAM ISRAEL      Pitchers: Charlie Beilenson (Seattle Mariners, MLB, ) Josh Blum (New York Mets, MLB, )* Matt Bowman (Minnesota Twins, MLB, )* Harrison Cohen (New York Yankees, MLB, ) Daniel Federman (Unattached, ) Jordan Geber (New York Mets, MLB, )* Tommy Kahnle (Unattached, ) Rob Kaminsky (Staten Island FerryHawks, ALPB, ) Dean Kremer (Baltimore Orioles, MLB, ) Max Lazar (Philadelphia Phillies, MLB, ) Carlos Lequerica (Detroit Tigers, MLB, )* Josh Mallitz (San Diego Padres, MLB, )* Eli Morgan (Kansas City Royals, MLB, )* Ryan Prager (Cleveland Guardians, MLB, )* Ben Simon (New York Mets, MLB, )* Robert Stock (New York Mets, MLB, )* Zack Weiss (Unattached, )   Catchers: C.J. Stubbs (Toronto Blue Jays, MLB, )* Garrett Stubbs (Philadelphia Phillies, MLB, )   Infielders: Cole Carrigg (Colorado Rockies, MLB, ) Jake Gelof (Los Angeles Dodgers, MLB, )* Spencer Horwitz (Pittsburgh Pirates, MLB, ) Noah Mendlinger (St. Louis Cardinals, MLB, )* Matt Mervis (Washington Nationals, MLB, )* Benjamin Rosengard (Idaho Falls Chukars, Pioneer League, )   Outfielders: Harrison Bader (San Francisco Giants, MLB, ) Troy Johnston (Colorado Rockies, MLB, ) Zach Levenson (St. Louis Cardinals, MLB, )* Assaf Lowengart (Unattached, ) RJ Schreck (Toronto Blue Jays, MLB, )   *minor league player
    • TEAM COLOMBIA      Pitchers: Elkin Alcala (Charros de Jalisco, LMB, ) Adrian Almeida (Rieleros de Aguascalientes, LMB, ) Austin Bergner (Texas Rangers, MLB, )* Danis Correa (Caneros de Los Mochis, LMP, ) Nabil Crismatt (Texas Rangers, MLB, )* Pedro Garcia (Bravos de Leon, LMB, ) Rio Gomez (Unattached, ) Yapson Gomez (Tiburones de La Guaira, LVBP, ) Tayron Guerrero (Boston Red Sox, MLB, ) David Lorduy (Cincinnati Reds, MLB, )* Emerson Martinez (Tiburones de La Guaira, LVBP, ) Luis Patino (Diablos Rojos del Mexico, LMB, )* Jose Quintana (Unattached, ) Jhon Romero (Tigres de Aragua, LVBP, ) Reiver Sanmartin (San Francisco Giants, MLB, )* Julio Teheran (Unattached, ) Guillo Zuniga (Seattle Mariners, MLB, )   Catchers: Jorge Alfaro (Kansas City Royals, MLB, ) Elias Diaz (Unattached, ) Carlos Martinez (Saraperos de Saltillo, LMB, )   Infielders: Michael Arroyo (Seattle Mariners, MLB, ) Jordan Diaz (Gigantes del Cibao, LIDOM, ) Dayan Frias (Cleveland Guardians, MLB, ) Reynaldo Rodriguez (Caliente de Durango, LMB, ) Donovan Solano (Unattached, ) Gio Urshela (Unattached, )   Outfielders: Brayan Buelvas (Athletics, MLB, )* Gustavo Campero (Los Angeles Angels, MLB, )* Jesus Marriaga (Saraperos de Saltillo, LMB, ) Harold Ramirez (Tecos de los Dos Laredos, LMB, )   *minor league player
×
×
  • Create New...