website statistics
Jump to content
  • Register/Login on Totallympics!

    Sign up to Totallympics to get full access to our website.

     

    Registration is free and allows you to participate in our community. You will then be able to reply to threads and access all pages.

     

    If you encounter any issues in the registration process, please send us a message in the Contact Us page.

     

    We are excited to see you on Totallympics, the home of Olympic Sports!

     

Athletics IAAF World Championships 2017


Recommended Posts

In the Makwala-case it's really hard to know who to judge, there's no way we know all the details. He might as well have lied to be able to skip the 200m but still run the 400m (which he would not be allowed to do if he skipped the 200 for no reason).

.

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/636-athletics-iaaf-world-championships-2017/page/133/#findComment-92346
Share on other sites

Oh yes and 4. for allowing a transgender athlete with proven advantage over the others to take away the hard work of the rest of the competitors... IAAF please act asap on the sex or gender issue.

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/636-athletics-iaaf-world-championships-2017/page/133/#findComment-92347
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, heywoodu said:

In the Makwala-case it's really hard to know who to judge, there's no way we know all the details. He might as well have lied to be able to skip the 200m but still run the 400m (which he would not be allowed to do if he skipped the 200 for no reason).

 He was stopped yesterday at the entrance of the stadium because of a  compulsory 48h quarantine. The Botswana federation found about that after they reported Makwala sick.

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/636-athletics-iaaf-world-championships-2017/page/133/#findComment-92349
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, stefanbg said:

 He was stopped yesterday at the entrance of the stadium because of a  compulsory 48h quarantine. The Botswana federation found about that after they reported Makwala sick.

And apparently other teams already knew about this, so one might still wonder: is there no possiblity that the fault lies with Botswana's team? Or is it IAAF's fault because they are the big bad federation, so by definition in a case like this it's their fault? 

.

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/636-athletics-iaaf-world-championships-2017/page/133/#findComment-92350
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, stefanbg said:

Oh yes and 4. for allowing a transgender athlete with proven advantage over the others to take away the hard work of the rest of the competitors... IAAF please act asap on the sex or gender issue.

That is just as incorrect as the frustrated people saying she is a man (which she isn't). 

 

Nothing to do with opinion by the way, calling her a man or transgender is simply factually incorrect. 

Edited by heywoodu

.

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/636-athletics-iaaf-world-championships-2017/page/133/#findComment-92351
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, stefanbg said:

Oh yes and 4. for allowing a transgender athlete with proven advantage over the others to take away the hard work of the rest of the competitors... IAAF please act asap on the sex or gender issue.

Again with this...even the study which was financed for this was not able to show that the "proven advantage" is comparable to the advantage of a man against a woman (but more similar to the advantage that other women have in their events).

Link to comment
https://totallympics.com/forums/topic/636-athletics-iaaf-world-championships-2017/page/133/#findComment-92352
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Posts around Totallympics

    • Filip Gravenfors (freestyle skiing)   Broke his collarbone during Sweden’s pre-Olympic training camp    https://www.instagram.com/p/DUD6BfYgqQO/?igsh=MXNoMjBjaWlyazc1OA==   All the best in your recovery Filip!
    • Entries nominated by the different NOC´s in the first post of this thread.    in the team event without pair, is one of the most WTF moment in history of the olympics
    • Very nice analysis, a few things here.   Bobsleigh: In Love's last 7 races, she hasn't finished better than 8th, unlikely she’ll medal. Also just a small correction, it's Kailie, you must've got her confused with someone else  Short Track Speed Skating: I'd say there's a really good chance you win at least 2-3 medals. Stoddard has been on fire this season, she's won 8 medals in 12 events, Santos Griswold has a decent chance in each of the women's distances, mainly the 500m. Women's relay won medals at two of the WCs, and the mixed relay has a chance if other top nations (Korea, Netherlands, Canada, China) crash in the semifinals, don't think they match up raw power wise.  Snowboarding: Choi, Shimizu, and possibly Kudo (more inconsistent) will push Kim if she is indeed at her best, but it's hard to bet against someone like her. Mastro is an outside chance in halfpipe, competition might be too much for her. Men's snowboard cross has no chance , and mixed team with Gaskill/Baumgartener or Vedder is probably an outside chance. 
    • Poland, he is employe in this airport ( i mean a brave)      
    • Someone has to tally USA up, I'll make it as short as I can.   Alpine Skiing: 2-5. Shiffrin and Vonn have a chance to medal in any event they are a part of. Small chance for a men's athlete to medal like in 2022. 1 gold and 1 silver to Shiffrin. Gold in women's team. 3 total. Bobsled: 1-3. Women's monobob team has the former gold medalist (Lindsey Humphries), the most recent world champion (Kayasha Love), and a medalist in both (Elana Meyers Taylor). Two medals in the event is very possible with a two woman as a chance. 1 gold in monobob Cross-Country ski: 1-4. Jesse Diggins has been ripping up the world circuit since her 2022 silver in 30km free and bronze in sprint. She'll get another medal this year, and could go for a legacy games with 4. 2 gold and 1 silver to diggins. So 3 total Figure Skating: 3-5. Ilia Malinin for men's, Madison Chock and Evan Bates for ice dancing, and the team event are some of the safest medals for team USA. I would expect another medal or two from the women's singles, but it's thin ice there between 2 medals or 0 in that event. 1 gold to Ilia, Chock and Bates, and the team. 1 silver to Liu in women's. 4 total Freestyle skiing: 6-11. The best winter sport for team USA, with 8 medals in the last Olympics and 9 at the 2025 worlds. High medal chances in men's aerials, slope, half and women's dual moguls, aerials, and mixed aerial teams. Good chances in men's big air and women's single moguls. Double medals in the strongest events is also likely. I'd say 9 is reasonable as the inclusion of double moguls could give 1-3 just in the women's event. 9 in total, too many to count Ice Hockey: 1-2. The women's team medals, they have done it every time and shouldn't stop this year. An NHL lead men's team should be getting a medal but a chance encounter with Canada could slow things down. Gold or silver for women's, bronze for men's. 2 Short Track Speed Skating: 0-1. There's 8 events the US has qualified for, it's a chaotic sport, one odd medal seems possible but not likely. 0 likely Skeleton: 0-1. Mystique Ro won 2 medals at the most recent world's albeit on home ice in Lake Placid. She has 2 chances to show up in individual and mixed relay and could win a medal. Bronze to Ro. 1 Snowboard: 0-4. This is a rough year for US snowboarding. Although we invented the sport, like skateboarding, the Japanese have mastered it. Chole Kim sits as the sole star for the team and if she's recovered from her recent injury should win halfpipe, but it's a looming question. There's chances in men's slope and big air from Ollie Martin or maybe Red Gerrard. The 4th medal would come from Men's snowboard cross where there's 4 top athletes. Maybe a bit harsh, we could go 5 or 6 if things align, but we could also reasonably get nothing. 3 seems doable, 1 gold to Kim, 1 bronze to Marin, 1 cross medal in men's or mixed team. 3 Speed skating: 3-6.  I had no idea the US team was this strong. Jordan Stolz is that guy and based on recent championships should medal in the 3 shortest distances if not win a few. Add in a very strong team pursuit squad for men's and a top 5 women's team and good athletes in the mass start event and we could see this as US's second best sport. 3 medals to Stolz, one in men's pursuit. 4 So tallied up the range is 17-42, which is basically a meaningless range to be honest because neither extreme is possible. I went back over and gave an official prediction with 30 medals total. 5 more then in Beijing. Maybe optimistic, but I think that makes sense with extra chances in double moguls, a stronger men's hockey team, and the Stolz having a good games. Reasonable range is 24-32
    • Basically, that. I'd be a bit more hopeful on alpine skiing (1-2) . Noël + Rassat make for a very, very good chance in men's slalom by itself and all the other outsiders + the men's team make for a solid second shot IMO.  Also, Laffont has been back this week-end and it seems she was doing good. I had a go before reading your post, and it was almost exactly the same for the other disciplines: Alpine : 1-2 Biathlon : 6-10 (yes, exactly the same range) Nordic : 0-1 Snowboarding : 2 Freestyle : 1-2 (including a fit Laffont) Ski Mountaineering : 2-3 Speed Skating ; 0-1 Figure skating : 1 Total : 13-22 (let's say 17-18)
    • All the Olympic Qualifying Events which have released the official qualification systems have been added to our calendars here:   2026 Qualification Calendar   2027 Qualification Calendar   2028 Qualification Calendar   You can easily access these calendars from this menu everywhere:         If you spot any missing qualification event please report it to me here!
    • For  Marielle Thompson and Mikael Kingsbury   @hckošice
×
×
  • Create New...