Short Track Speed Skating ISU World Championships 2019

[phelps 8,766]

Just now, heywoodu said:

This is getting boring though, you can barely do anything or you're kicked out. What's left of the sport when people are DQ'ed who are hit by others? (like yesterday, a Chinese girl I believe was penalized after someone hit her hard, who was in turn advanced )

 

I agree...it's a lot like modern keirin in track cycling...it's no longer the exciting sport it used to be...

 

but still, if those rules are in place, you have to play according to them...and someone is not always doing that...

 

p.s. yesterday, it was Seidel who was advanced despite being guilty of that crash...

[phelps 8,766]

I fear De Laat's going home...

[phelps 8,766]

and here it comes...De Laat out and the second Korean advanced to the A-Final...

[heywoodu 16,468]

Just now, phelps said:

 

I agree...it's a lot like modern keirin in track cycling...it's no longer the exciting sport it used to be...

 

but still, if those rules are in place, you have to play according to them...and someone is not always doing that...

 

p.s. yesterday, it was Seidel who was advanced despite being guilty of that crash...

Yeah, I meant Seidel. That was just outright stupid: crashing out someone else, falling together with that person and you get advanced while your victim gets penalized  

 

It's like you shoot someone in the legs and while doing so, the backfire hurts your hand, after which the judge sends your victim to jail and you get money for the damage to your hand  

[Monzanator 5,136]

There are way too many DQs in short track compared to like 5-6 years ago. And it's hard to watch when the video review lasts longer than the race itself. That's why I don't follow this event on live TV. I watched two 1500 SFs, saw the Schulting BS and I turned it off.

[phelps 8,766]

Just now, heywoodu said:

Yeah, I meant Seidel. That was just outright stupid: crashing out someone else, falling together with that person and you get advanced while your victim gets penalized  

 

It's like you shoot someone in the legs and while doing so, the backfire hurts your hand, after which the judge sends your victim to jail and you get money for the damage to your hand  

 

if the judge is Italian, it's highly likely to happen...

[phelps 8,766]

Just now, Monzanator said:

There are way too many DQs in short track compared to like 5-6 years ago. And it's hard to watch when the video review lasts longer than the race itself. That's why I don't follow this event on live TV. I watched two 1500 SFs, saw the Schulting BS and I turned it off.

 

in the last few years, they repeatedly changed the rules for safety reasons...

that's why nowadays almost nothing is allowed anymore..you just have to keep your line and skate as fast as you can...

Edited March 9, 2019 by phelps

[heywoodu 16,468]

Just now, Monzanator said:

There are way too many DQs in short track compared to like 5-6 years ago. And it's hard to watch when the video review lasts longer than the race itself. That's why I don't follow this event on live TV. I watched two 1500 SFs, saw the Schulting BS and I turned it off.

Interestingly, ex-shorttrack skater Niels Kerstholt (also Dutch, he's in the TV studio) was very much agreeing with the penalty and called Schulting's defending 'incredibly stupid'  

 

I don't watch it live a lot anymore though, usually I watch the replays so I can skip through the eternal waits  

[phelps 8,766]

men's 1500m, Skaters qualified to the A-Final

Steven Dubois

Samuel Girard

Xu Hongzhi

Hwang Dae Heon

Keita Watanabe

Lee June Seo

Lim Hyo Jun

Semen Elistratov

[phelps 8,766]

Just now, heywoodu said:

Interestingly, ex-shorttrack skater Niels Kerstholt (also Dutch, he's in the TV studio) was very much agreeing with the penalty and called Schulting's defending 'incredibly stupid'  

 

I don't watch it live a lot anymore though, usually I watch the replays so I can skip through the eternal waits  

 

as I wrote before, Schulting's mistake was actually evident and "stupid" (at least, really unnecessary)...

other calls, instead, were at least more questionable...

Edited March 9, 2019 by phelps