Winter Olympic Games 2022 Olympic Sports Programme

[dcro 7,409]

2 minutes ago, heywoodu said:

It's easy for me: everything that's done on snow and/or ice is a winter sport, all the rest are season-neutral sports, some of which are mostly played in summer, some mostly in winter.

 

That doesn't make sense. If summer sports are considered "season-neutral", it's the same for winter ones (after all, they can all be played indoors).

[heywoodu 9,216]

1 minute ago, dcro said:

 

That doesn't make sense. If summer sports are considered "season-neutral", it's the same for winter ones (after all, they can all be played indoors).

But alpine skiing, cross-country skiing, biathlon, ski jumping etc are basically never done indoors, with a rare exception here and there, making them as good as completely winter sports. Volleyball, handball, basketball, swimming etc are mostly done indoors in competition form. Obviously not winter sports, but definitely not completely summer sports neither (since a majority of competitions doesn't need any summer to exist whatsoever, whereas a huge majority of winter sports competitions is cancelled if there's no winter).

[dcro 7,409]

25 minutes ago, heywoodu said:

But alpine skiing, cross-country skiing, biathlon, ski jumping etc are basically never done indoors, with a rare exception here and there, making them as good as completely winter sports. Volleyball, handball, basketball, swimming etc are mostly done indoors in competition form. Obviously not winter sports, but definitely not completely summer sports neither (since a majority of competitions doesn't need any summer to exist whatsoever, whereas a huge majority of winter sports competitions is cancelled if there's no winter).

 

But there is such thing as indoor alpine skiing. While for example there is no such thing as indoor trap shooting, or indoor sailing, or indoor canoeing, etc. Your definition uses double standards, as in theory winter sports also don't NEED winter to exist.

 

It's not solely about moving sports indoors anyway. It's about recreating summer conditions for indoor summer sports, and recreating winter conditions for indoor winter sports. It's not like a volleyball match can be played if it's -10 degrees inside or something.

Edited November 7, 2018 by dcro

[heywoodu 9,216]

I am starting to lose track of what the whole point of this discussion is anyway. I just want to see ice track cycling. 

[Col_Frost 176]

58 minut temu, heywoodu napisał:

I am starting to lose track of what the whole point of this discussion is anyway. I just want to see ice track cycling. 

Maybe try ice speedway? Competitors also drive around sitting on two-wheels vehicles. The only different is that vehicles are making "broom-broom" noise  

[heywoodu 9,216]

1 minute ago, Col_Frost said:

Maybe try ice speedway? Competitors also drive around sitting on two-wheels vehicles. The only different is that vehicles are making "broom-broom" noise  

The bigger difference is that vehicles are not powered by the athletes  

[Col_Frost 176]

Przed chwilą, heywoodu napisał:

The bigger difference is that vehicles are not powered by the athletes  

Of course they are! Vehicle won't go forward if driver won't turn gas on 

[heywoodu 9,216]

7 minutes ago, Col_Frost said:

Of course they are! Vehicle won't go forward if driver won't turn gas on 

Ok, let me rephrase it  The bigger difference is that vehicles are not mainly powered by the athletes